Wednesday, September 25, 2019

[Scotch Review] Bunnahabhain 1991 Duncan Taylor Dimensions



Big thanks to LOL_OILERS from Reddit for pouring me this one recently!

While I'll be heading to Bunnahabhain Distillery (along with some other distilleries on Islay and in Campbeltown) next week for a fun tour I'm not sure if they'll have anything quite this old in store for me, or even anything from the late 90s in general outside of the growingly pricey older bottlings thanks to the growing prestige of this distillery. Luckily for me though, /u/LOL_OILERS is also making the trip over to Islay just after I return back from the whisky isle so to help me prepare for my Bunnahabhain journey he decided to pour me this independent bottling of Bunnahabhain from Duncan Taylor's Dimensions line.

It's been a while since I've had a Duncan Taylor. Last year I had a really solid Glen Elgin from their line as well as an older Macduff that was a bit of a letdown. But Bunnahabhain is a bit of special distillery, especially at old ages going by the reviews I've had of a few 18 year old Bunnas (both OB and IB) so I'm excited to see how this distillery will fare at the 20 year old mark! So let's dive in and take a closer look!

_____________________________________________________

Age: 20 Years

Region: Islay

Cask Type(s): Oak Casks

ABV: 51.4%

No. of Bottles: 252

Maturation Time: Nov. 1991/Jun. 2012

_____________________________________________________

  • Color: Straw Gold
  • Nose: Very clean nose for a Bunna with a good dose of salinity, apple jam and sliced pear make the forefront appearance along with some baking spice, clove, cocoa powder, golden raisins, light almonds and sea salted caramels in the background
  • Taste: A very salinic palate again as well with lots of apples, pears, cinnamon and loads of honey, a lot of honey in fact, then some white pepper, lapsang, ginseng, escargot, light earthy peat and fresh but not tart lemon curds
  • Finish: Long with lingering soothing oiliness, salinity, apple and pear jams, lemon zest and clove


This is such a wonderful light bodied style of Bunnahabhain. The notes are composed nicely and strike a wonderful balance with each other and the palate has some great pronounced jelliness and honey with an evolution into more oily and saline qualities that last on your palate for over a minute. Adding water helps to open up more baking spices and raisins and make the palate a bit more full as well as make the finish even more pronounced and adds a bit more pepperiness but more entangled pepperiness that doesn't overpower the fruit and saline qualities. While it's not my favorite style of Bunnahabhain it's definitely one that's so easy to drink and so easy to pick apart that you could easily sit with this dram almost any day of the week and be satisfied even if it's not a tongue crusher with peat, heavy oak or heavy wine influences. The spirit shines so well and mingles nicely with what I'd imagine is a 2nd or 3rd fill bourbon hogshead to where it makes for a very signature expression of very faintly peated Bunnahabhain that's definitely worth giving a look into and possibly worth a buy.

86 pts

 

Thanks again for reading and make sure to follow me on instagram for newer updates @whiskyladdie! I will be heading to Scotland this weekend to tour various distilleries so make sure to follow me for pictures before I post some longer distillery write-ups here!


Current Review Scoring System:

 

0-49: Horrible

50-59: Bad

60-69: Mediocre to Average

70-74: Average to Good

75-79: Good to Great

80-84: Great to Excellent

85-89: Excellent

90-94: Superb

95+: Masterpiece

 

*Note that all images are owned by their respective owners, The Whisky Laddie does not receive financial compensation for this site's content. If this changes any copyrighted images will be replaced with originals made or solicited by the author of these posts.

[Scotch Review] Auchentoshan The Bartender's Malt No. 2


Back to trying another Auchentoshan and for me it's really hard to find higher ABV Auchentoshan's in the wild. Last year I tried a few more the usual, one being a 17 year old sherried SMWS bottling that was nicely put together and another a distillery bottling 21 year old small batch from 1975 that was super funky and If tasted blind could possibly have passed for a rum. However, outside of those two uncommon pours the usual crop of Auchentoshans that end up in stores are the epitome of undesirable for the seasoned whisky drinker. Most are 40% ABV, have caramel colouring added and are quite boring, but not bad whiskies in my opinion, even at the 21 year mark.

So when Auchentoshan announced their Bartender's Malt annual release line last year I became interested. For one it was proofed at 47% ABV and used some interesting casks, such as German oak and ex-Laphroaig casks, in the mix to create what is dubbed as a vatting of many casks selected by bartenders from around the world that they think would work the best in a variety of cocktails. While I'm not much of a cocktail guy I was still interested in the vatting idea and took a shot on the first edition. It was good stuff but a lot of whisky reviewers, specifically the many who rate whisky on whiskybase, weren't big fans. So now we're onto the 2nd edition of this series, now bottled at a higher 50% ABV while still priced at $75 CAD, which contains a vatting of whiskies as young as 4 years old and as old as 50 years old (according to whisky.com, although some others claim the youngest as 6 years and the oldest as 40 years but let's just say NAS for now). While I doubt there's more then a teaspoon of 50 year old whisky in the mix I'm still interested to see how this dram fares!

So let's take a look…

_____________________________________________________

Age: NAS

Region: Lowlands

Cask Type(s): Not Available

ABV: 50.0%

No. of Bottles: Not Available

Maturation Time: Bottled in 2018

_____________________________________________________

  • Color: Amber
  • Nose: Really nice cinnamon butter and puff pastry forward nose, cordial cherries, apple strudel, walnuts, raisins, lemon cream and dry cocoa powder along with a faint salinity
  • Taste: Very bourbon forward, almost reminiscent of the old Valinch but more tame and complex, lots of silky vanilla, hard caramels, ginger and cinnamon laced strudel, mincemeat tarts, cherry preserve, rose wine and touches of black pepper
  • Finish: Long with more pepper, dry ginger, walnuts and tangerines


A really subtle yet well put together whisky. The pastry forward nose doesn't really show up on the palate as much but the deep complexity of sweets, spice and nuttiness really make this a good easy sipping dram with a good body and a very long finish mostly thanks to the higher ABV and better cask selection compared to batch 1. While I'm not sure if this will appear to oaked to those who disliked the first edition, I didn't find the oak on this one as dominant as that one so I think some out there will be pleasantly surprised with this sequel. Overall, a very well put together Auchentoshan with touches of that 70s magic hidden within and for $75 CAD this one was well worth the buy. 

 

84 pts

 

Thanks again for reading and make sure to follow me on instagram for newer updates @whiskyladdie!

Current Review Scoring System:

 

0-49: Horrible

50-59: Bad

60-69: Mediocre to Average

70-74: Average to Good

75-79: Good to Great

80-84: Great to Excellent

85-89: Excellent

90-94: Superb

95+: Masterpiece

 

*Note that all images are owned by their respective owners, The Whisky Laddie does not receive financial compensation for this site's content. If this changes any copyrighted images will be replaced with originals made or solicited by the author of these posts.







Wednesday, September 4, 2019

[Scotch Review] Jack Wiebers Classic of Islay 2018


It's been a while since I've tried a whisky from Jack Wiebers Whisky World. The last two I had, a 20 year old bourbon cask Glenrothes and a 10 year old Croftengea (highly peated Loch Lomond malt), ranged from very good to just okay but I still missed the one Islay whisky this bottler did so I decided to pick one of them up. 2 years ago I tried an edition of the Classic of Islay series, supposedly independent bottlings of Lagavulin that are quite young but still in the 10+ year range, that I very much enjoyed and this one is a sister cask of sorts that I hadn't reviewed yet so I took a blind shot and grabbed a bottle.

It also helps that this was quite a bargain at $120 CAD after taxes, even more so if you're a lucky European with access to whisky shops in The Netherlands who have it for around 65 euros, a fair price to pay for what appears to be sherried Lagavulin. So let's see if this blind turned out alright! /u/the_muskox seemed to think so but let's have a good taste for the fun of it!

_____________________________________________________

Age: NAS

Region: Islay

Cask Type(s): Likely Refill Sherry Cask

ABV: 52.1%

No. of Bottles: Not Available

Maturation Time: Bottled in 2018

_____________________________________________________

  • Color: Light Amber
  • Nose: Super buttery with rich hits of cardamom, cinnamon stalk, candied cherries, olive oil, black tea leaves, ginger, orange oil and in the background some meaty bbq marinated pork chops (always welcome on a nice cool August weekend!)
  • Taste: Cloyingly sweet, lots of orange cream candy and maple syrup, then some cherry chewy candies, Cadbury Cream Egg filling, smoked paprika, pure sweet cream sherry and some rich bananas foster with extra brown sugar to boot
  • Finish: Medium to Long with soft baking spices, smoked pork fat and roasted mango flesh

This is easily the best Lagavulin (possibly?) I've had to date. Lot's of richness and complexity with a lovely mix of butteriness, spice and dessert sweetness that almost makes this an ideal bakers whisky of sort. For the price this went for in Alberta I might just get a few more because it's really good especially when it gets some time out of the bottle. Jack Wiebers does it again for me, maybe even moreso then the first time.

87 pts


Thanks again for reading and make sure to follow me on instagram for newer updates @whiskyladdie!

Current Review Scoring System:

 

0-49: Horrible

50-59: Bad

60-69: Mediocre to Average

70-74: Average to Good

75-79: Good to Great

80-84: Great to Excellent

85-89: Excellent

90-94: Superb

95+: Masterpiece

 

*Note that all images are owned by their respective owners, The Whisky Laddie does not receive financial compensation for this site's content. If this changes any copyrighted images will be replaced with originals made or solicited by the author of these posts.